Anonymous user
Majority Choice Approval: Difference between revisions
m
→Criteria compliance
imported>Homunq |
imported>Homunq |
||
Line 37:
Other criteria are satisfied by some, but not all, MCA variants. To wit:
* The [[Condorcet criterion]] is satisfied by MCA-
* [[Strategic nomination|Clone Independence]] is satisfied by most MCA versions. In fact, even the stronger [[Independence of irrelevant alternatives]] is satisfied by MCA-A, MCA-P, MCA-M, and MCA-S. Clone independence is satisfied along with the weaker and related [[ISDA]] by MCA-IR and MCA-AR, if ISDA-compliant Condorcet methods (ie, [[Schulze]]) are used to choose the two "finalists". Using simpler methods (such as MCA itself) to decide the finalists, MCA-IR and MCA-AR are not clone independent.
|