Method evaluation poll 2005: Difference between revisions

JG CB KV DK MO

[[Plurality]]

[[Runoff voting|Two round runoff]]

[[Approval voting|Approval]]

[[Random Ballot|Random Ballot]]

 

=== ranking input ===

==== not Condorcet-efficient ====

 

[[IRV]] without equal rankings

ER-IRV(whole)

ER-IRV(fractional)

[[Bucklin voting|Bucklin]] without equal rankings

[[ER-Bucklin|ER-Bucklin(whole)]]

[[ER-Bucklin|ER-Bucklin(fractional)]]

?

JG CB KV DK MO

[[MMPO|minmax(pairwise opposition)]]

[[CDTT|CDTT,IRV]]

7 9 6 ?

6? 9 ?

[[Majority Defeat Disqualification Approval]] ([[MDDA]])

 

==== Condorcet-efficient ====

6.5 8.5 6 3

[[CWP|approval weighted pairwise]] (e.g. with ranked pairs base)

[[approval margins]]

5.5 9 ? 3

=== rating input ===

 

[[range voting]] (ratings summation)

[[Median Ratings|median ratings]]

3 4 2

ranked pairs([[cardinal pairwise]])

beatpath([[cardinal pairwise]])

 

=== other ===

JG DK MO

[[candidate withdrawal option|CWO]]-ER-IRV(whole)

[[candidate withdrawal option|CWO]]-ER-IRV(fractional)

[[candidate withdrawal option|CWO]]-ranked pairs(WV)

[[candidate withdrawal option|CWO]]-ranked ballot plurality

6 1

[[MMPO|minmax(pairwise opposition)]] with [[AERLO and ATLO]]

[[MMPO]] with AERLO, ATLO, & [[Power Truncation]]

[[MMPO]] with (only) [[Power Truncation]]

[[beatpath]](WV) with AERLO and ATLO

[[beatpath]](WV) with [[strong/weak preference option]]

[[random jury]] method

 

== See also ==