Reciprocal Score Voting: Difference between revisions

Line 123:
RSV suffers from a "reverse spoiler effect" in which a large faction may lose by not supporting a smaller faction. This can be a major problem when the smaller faction is a group with fringe or too radical beliefs compared to the main faction.
 
Since such fringe groups would likely be universally hated by every other faction, one way to partially address this is to additionally adjust the reciprocity ratiosratio factors to include the total ratings given to each faction, that is, if a fringe faction gets an overall low mean score, then that low mean score is used to lower the penalty of not reciprocating with that faction. This way, sufficiently fringe factions largely give asymmetric support towards more mainstream factions. Between similar mainstream factions, which would receive similar overall mean scores, the effect cancels out and RSV proceeds as normal.
 
This way, sufficiently fringe factions largely give asymmetric support towards more mainstream factions, making reciprocation with them less necessary. Between similar largely acceptable factions, which would receive similar overall mean scores, the effect cancels out and RSV proceeds as normal.
 
Therefore, by taking into account mutual reciprocation as well as overall ratings RSV can be made to promote reciprocation only between factions that have similar levels of overall support.
 
=== Passed/Failed criteria ===
295

edits