Approval Sorted Margins: Difference between revisions
Content added Content deleted
(→Sorted Margins heuristic: (Notes on Method) swap X with Y for clarity) |
(Modify criteria satisfaction, add Score Sorted Margins references) |
||
Line 273: | Line 273: | ||
# [[Plurality criterion]] |
# [[Plurality criterion]] |
||
# the winner is always chosen from the [[Immune set]] |
# the winner is always chosen from the [[Immune set]] |
||
# [[Chicken Dilemma criterion ]] ''(incompatible with [[Minimal Defense criterion]])'' |
|||
# the winner is always chosen from the [[CDTT|CDTT set]] |
|||
# [[Minimal Defense criterion]] |
|||
# [[Strategy-Free criterion]] |
# [[Strategy-Free criterion]] |
||
# [[Generalized Strategy-Free criterion]] |
# [[Generalized Strategy-Free criterion]] |
||
Line 288: | Line 287: | ||
# [[Consistency|Consistency criterion]] |
# [[Consistency|Consistency criterion]] |
||
# [[Tactical voting|invulnerability to compromising]] |
# [[Tactical voting|invulnerability to compromising]] |
||
# [[Tactical voting|invulnerability to burying]] |
# [[Tactical voting|invulnerability to burying]] ''(but has higher resistance than [[Beatpath]])'' |
||
# [[Favorite Betrayal criterion]] |
# [[Favorite Betrayal criterion]] |
||
# [[Later-no-harm criterion]] |
# [[Later-no-harm criterion]] |
||
''(TODO: check and find examples)'' |
''(TODO: check and find examples)'' |
||
== Score Sorted Margins variation == |
|||
Instead of using an explicit approval cutoff, one can apply the Sorted Margins procedure to an initial seed ordering based on total score sum. |
|||
With sufficiently large range, ''e.g.'', zero to five or zero to 10, Score Sorted Margins usually yields the same winner as Approval Sorted Margins with a an appproval cutoff of Floor(MAXSCORE / 2). |
|||
== References == |
== References == |
||
[https://github.com/dodecatheon/approval-sorted-margins] GitHub python code that compares Approval Sorted Margins to other Condorcet methods with explicit approval cutoff. |
[https://github.com/dodecatheon/approval-sorted-margins] GitHub python code that compares Approval Sorted Margins to other Condorcet methods with explicit approval cutoff. See also '''ScoreSM.py''', a command-line python script to run Score Sorted Margins as a Droop quota-based score reweighted voting method. |
||
---- |
---- |