Jump to content

Prefer Accept Reject voting: Difference between revisions

imported>Homunq
No edit summary
imported>Homunq
Line 18:
== Criteria compliance ==
 
PAR voting passes the [[majority criterion]], the [[mutual majority criterion]], the [[majority loser criterion]], [[Local independence of irrelevant alternatives]] (under the assumption of fixed "honest" ratings for each voter for each candidate), [[Independence of clone alternatives]], [[Monotonicity]], [[polytime]], [[resolvability]], and O(N²) [[summability]]. (It is also possible to run it in no more than 3 counting rounds, each of which is O(N) summable.)
 
There are a few criteria for which it does not pass as such, but where it passes related but weaker criteria. These include:
Line 24:
* It fails [[Independence of irrelevant alternatives]], but passes [[Local independence of irrelevant alternatives]].
 
* It fails the [[Condorcet criterion]], but forpasses anythe set of voters such that an honestvoted majority Condorcet winner exists, there always exists a strong equilibrium set of strictly semi-honest ballots that elects that CWcriterion. (Note that this is not true for any strictly-ranked Condorcet system!)
 
* It fails the [[participation criterion]] but passes the [[semi-honest participation criterion]].
 
* It fails O(N)the [[summabilitylater-no-help criterion]], but canpasses getif thatthere summabilityis withat two-passleast tallyingone (firstcandidate determinerejected who's disqualified,by thenunder retally)50%.
 
* It may passfails the majority[[consistency criterion]], the [[Condorcet loser criterion]], (?)[[reversibility]], the [[Strategy-free criterion]], and the [[later-no-harm criterion]].
 
* It fails the [[later-no-help criterion]], but passes if there is at least one candidate above the qualification thresholds (which is always true, for instance, if there are some three candidates who get 3 different ratings on every ballot).
 
It fails the [[consistency criterion]], the [[Condorcet loser criterion]], [[reversibility]], the [[Strategy-free criterion]], and the [[later-no-harm criterion|later-no-harm]] criterion.
 
=== Favorite betrayal? ===
Anonymous user
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.