Three Telos Model: Difference between revisions

(→‎Historical Context: Add citation)
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1:
The '''Three Telos Model''' or "Triangle Political Map" or "Political Trichotomy" is a explanatory model of political ideology. It's a way to describe political beliefs based on the core axiom of the philosophy called a [[W:Telos | telos]]. The Three Telos Model is based on the concept of a [[w:ternary plot | ternary plot]] where the different underlying philosophies can be mixed but must sum up to the totality of the of the persons ideological position. This is a departure from the standard cartesian spaces such as the two-dimensional [[political spectrum]].
 
The core concept is that there are three teloses or axiomatic end goals which are fundamentally incompatible with each other. Favoring any one telos comes at the expense of another.<ref>https://www.amazon.ca/Challenge-Democracy-American-Government-Politics/dp/1305954920</ref> In this way the model is an attempt to show how differing balances of core values result in different ideological positions.
 
[[File:Politics map triangle1.png]]
 
ItWhile the origin of this model remains uncertain, a likely candidate is [[W:Rudolph Rummel|Rudolph Rummel's]] 1976 book [https://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/TCH.CHAP31.HTM#3 Understanding Conflict and War, Vol. 2: The Conflict Helix]. There are some similarities to a concept described by [[W:Mary Douglas | Mary Douglas]] in her earlier book [[W:Natural Symbols | Natural Symbols]]. The Three Telos Model can be thought of as being [[W: M-theory#Dualities | dual]] to Douglas' [https://psychology.wikia.org/wiki/Cultural_theory_of_risk Grid-Group Cultural Theory] in the sense that each can be transformed in some way so that it ends up looking just like the other theory. There are some similarities in approach to [[W:Theory of Basic Human Values | Schwartz's Theory of Basic Human Values]] and [[W:Rokeach Value Survey | Rokeach's Value Survey]]. The [https://8values.github.io/ 8values] test is also very similar since it uses 3 of the Teloses in a four dimensional cartesian space.
 
There areis severalno slightcanonical variationsversion of thisthe model but they are similar enough to each other and distinct enough from other models to be grouped. A sample of various implementations by political pundits are in the following videos:
 
* "ShortFatOtaku"<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LA9dFRCX0KM&feature=youtu.be|title=Liberty, Fraternity, Equality|last=ShortFatOtaku|first=|date=|website=youtube.com/user/ShortFatOtaku|url-status=live|archive-url=|archive-date=|access-date=2021-01-14}}</ref>
Line 41:
|It is fair and reduces harm
|People have a need for self-determination
|Tradition is a set of solutions for which we have forgotten the problems
|Traditions provide order and something for individuals to unify around
|-
|Philosophical Foundation
|[[W: Jean-Jacques Rousseau | Rousseau]], [[W: Young Hegelians |Young Hegelians]], [[W: Critical theory |Critical theory]] and Marxism
|[[W: Classical liberalism |Liberalism]] and [[W: Age of Enlightenment | Enlightenment]] [[W: Humanism |Humanism]]
|Ancient philosophy and [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_Hegelians Right Hegelians]
Line 112:
|Civil Liberties/Private Property
|Tradition/Structure
|-
| [[W: Phobia | Phobia]]
| [[W: Oikophobia | Oikophobia]]
|tyrannophobia
| [[W: Xenophobia | Xenophobia]]
|-
| [[W:Cultural theory of risk | Grid-Group Culture]] <ref>https://psychology.wikia.org/wiki/Cultural_theory_of_risk</ref>
Line 146 ⟶ 151:
 
Furthermore to this, there is a large dependency on the dynamics. People with differing position in the Three Telos Model will act differently depending on what the dominant ideology is, the rate of change and the direction of change relative to their position. For example the work of [[W:Karen Stenner | Karen Stenner]] has shown that Authoritarians (those low in the Telos of liberty) become much more authoritarian when there is social instability or their sacred values are threatened.
 
==Tests==
 
* [https://crystalvulpine.github.io/PoliticalTriangle-old/ Crystalvulpine's Implementation]
 
== References ==
765

edits