Largest remainder method: Difference between revisions
Psephomancy (talk | contribs) (Add wikitable class to a bunch of tables using MassEditRegex) |
Psephomancy (talk | contribs) (table header cells) |
||
Line 35: | Line 35: | ||
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
||
<tr> |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Party</th> |
||
< |
<th>A</th> |
||
< |
<th>B</th> |
||
< |
<th>C</th> |
||
< |
<th>D</th> |
||
< |
<th>E</th> |
||
< |
<th>F</th> |
||
< |
<th>Total</th> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Votes</th> |
||
<td >1500</td> |
<td >1500</td> |
||
<td >1500</td> |
<td >1500</td> |
||
Line 54: | Line 54: | ||
<td >5100</td> |
<td >5100</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Seats</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 64: | Line 64: | ||
<td >25</td> |
<td >25</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Hare Quota</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 74: | Line 74: | ||
<td >204</td> |
<td >204</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Quotas Received</th> |
||
<td >7.35</td> |
<td >7.35</td> |
||
<td >7.35</td> |
<td >7.35</td> |
||
Line 84: | Line 84: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Automatic seats</th> |
||
<td >7</td> |
<td >7</td> |
||
<td >7</td> |
<td >7</td> |
||
Line 94: | Line 94: | ||
<td >22</td> |
<td >22</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Remainder</th> |
||
<td >0.35</td> |
<td >0.35</td> |
||
<td >0.35</td> |
<td >0.35</td> |
||
Line 104: | Line 104: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Surplus seats</th> |
||
<td >0</td> |
<td >0</td> |
||
<td >0</td> |
<td >0</td> |
||
Line 114: | Line 114: | ||
<td >3</td> |
<td >3</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Total Seats </th> |
||
<td >7</td> |
<td >7</td> |
||
<td >7</td> |
<td >7</td> |
||
Line 129: | Line 129: | ||
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
||
<tr> |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Party</th> |
||
< |
<th>A</th> |
||
< |
<th>B</th> |
||
< |
<th>C</th> |
||
< |
<th>D</th> |
||
< |
<th>E</th> |
||
< |
<th>F</th> |
||
< |
<th>Total</th> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Votes</th> |
||
<td >1500</td> |
<td >1500</td> |
||
<td >1500</td> |
<td >1500</td> |
||
Line 148: | Line 148: | ||
<td >5100</td> |
<td >5100</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Seats</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 158: | Line 158: | ||
<td >26</td> |
<td >26</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Hare Quota</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 168: | Line 168: | ||
<td >196</td> |
<td >196</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Quotas Received</th> |
||
<td >7.65</td> |
<td >7.65</td> |
||
<td >7.65</td> |
<td >7.65</td> |
||
Line 178: | Line 178: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Automatic seats</th> |
||
<td >7</td> |
<td >7</td> |
||
<td >7</td> |
<td >7</td> |
||
Line 188: | Line 188: | ||
<td >23</td> |
<td >23</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Remainder</th> |
||
<td >0.65</td> |
<td >0.65</td> |
||
<td >0.65</td> |
<td >0.65</td> |
||
Line 198: | Line 198: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Surplus seats</th> |
||
<td >1</td> |
<td >1</td> |
||
<td >1</td> |
<td >1</td> |
||
Line 208: | Line 208: | ||
<td >3</td> |
<td >3</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Total Seats </th> |
||
<td >8</td> |
<td >8</td> |
||
<td >8</td> |
<td >8</td> |
||
Line 227: | Line 227: | ||
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
||
<tr> |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Party</th> |
||
< |
<th>Yellows</th> |
||
< |
<th>Whites</th> |
||
< |
<th>Reds</th> |
||
< |
<th>Greens</th> |
||
< |
<th>Blues</th> |
||
< |
<th>Pinks</th> |
||
< |
<th>Total</th> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Votes</th> |
||
<td >47,000</td> |
<td >47,000</td> |
||
<td >16,000</td> |
<td >16,000</td> |
||
Line 246: | Line 246: | ||
<td >100,000</td> |
<td >100,000</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Seats</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 256: | Line 256: | ||
<td >10</td> |
<td >10</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Hare Quota</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 266: | Line 266: | ||
<td >10,000</td> |
<td >10,000</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Votes/Quota</th> |
||
<td >4.70</td> |
<td >4.70</td> |
||
<td >1.60</td> |
<td >1.60</td> |
||
Line 276: | Line 276: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Automatic seats</th> |
||
<td >4</td> |
<td >4</td> |
||
<td >1</td> |
<td >1</td> |
||
Line 286: | Line 286: | ||
<td >7</td> |
<td >7</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Remainder</th> |
||
<td >0.70</td> |
<td >0.70</td> |
||
<td >0.60</td> |
<td >0.60</td> |
||
Line 296: | Line 296: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Highest Remainder Seats </th> |
||
<td >1</td> |
<td >1</td> |
||
<td >1</td> |
<td >1</td> |
||
Line 306: | Line 306: | ||
<td >3</td> |
<td >3</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Total Seats </th> |
||
<td >5</td> |
<td >5</td> |
||
<td >2</td> |
<td >2</td> |
||
Line 321: | Line 321: | ||
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
<table class="wikitable" border="1"> |
||
<tr > |
<tr > |
||
< |
<th>Party</th> |
||
< |
<th>Yellows</th> |
||
< |
<th>Whites</th> |
||
< |
<th>Reds</th> |
||
< |
<th>Greens</th> |
||
< |
<th>Blues</th> |
||
< |
<th>Pinks</th> |
||
< |
<th>Total</th> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Votes</th> |
||
<td >47,000</td> |
<td >47,000</td> |
||
<td >16,000</td> |
<td >16,000</td> |
||
Line 340: | Line 340: | ||
<td >100,000</td> |
<td >100,000</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Seats</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 350: | Line 350: | ||
<td >10</td> |
<td >10</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Droop Quota</th> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
Line 360: | Line 360: | ||
<td >9,091</td> |
<td >9,091</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Votes/Quota </th> |
||
<td >5.170</td> |
<td >5.170</td> |
||
<td >1.760</td> |
<td >1.760</td> |
||
Line 370: | Line 370: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Automatic seats </th> |
||
<td >5</td> |
<td >5</td> |
||
<td >1</td> |
<td >1</td> |
||
Line 380: | Line 380: | ||
<td >8</td> |
<td >8</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Remainder</th> |
||
<td >0.170</td> |
<td >0.170</td> |
||
<td >0.760</td> |
<td >0.760</td> |
||
Line 390: | Line 390: | ||
<td > </td> |
<td > </td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Highest Remainder Seats </th> |
||
<td >0</td> |
<td >0</td> |
||
<td >1</td> |
<td >1</td> |
||
Line 400: | Line 400: | ||
<td >2</td> |
<td >2</td> |
||
</tr> |
</tr> |
||
<tr |
<tr> |
||
< |
<th>Total Seats </th> |
||
<td >5</td> |
<td >5</td> |
||
<td >2</td> |
<td >2</td> |
Revision as of 13:41, 2 September 2018
The largest remainder method is one way of allocating seats proportionally for representative assemblies with party list voting systems. It is a contrast to the highest averages method.
Method
The largest remainder method requires the number of votes for each party to be divided a quota representing the number of votes required for a seat, and this gives a notional number of seats to each, usually including an integer and either a fraction or alternatively a remainder. Each party receives seats equal to the integer. This will generally leave some seats unallocated: the parties are then ranked on the basis of the fraction or equivalently on the basis of the remainder, and parties with the larger fractions or remainders are each allocated one additional seat until all the seats have been allocated. This gives the method its name.
Quotas
There are several possibilities for the quota. The most common are: the Hare quota and the Droop quota.
The Hare Quota is defined as follows
The Hamilton method of apportionment is actually a largest-remainder method which is specifically defined as using the Hare Quota. It is used for legislative elections in Namibia and in the territory of Hong Kong. It was historically applied for congressional apportionment in the United States during the nineteenth century.
The Droop quota is the integer part of
and is applied in elections in South Africa.
The Hare quota tends to be slightly more generous to less popular parties and the Droop quota to more popular parties. Which is more proportional depends on what measure of proportionality is used.
The Imperiali quota
is rarely used since it suffers from the problem that it may result in more candidates being elected than there are seats available; this will certainly happen if there are only two parties. In such a case, it is usual to increase the quota until the number of candidates elected is equal to the number of seats available, in effect changing the voting system to a highest averages system with the Jefferson apportionment formula.
Technical evaluation and paradoxes
The largest remainder method is the only apportionment that satisfies the quota rule; in fact, it is designed to satisfy this criterion. However, it comes at the cost of paradoxical behaviour. The Alabama paradox is defined as when an increase in seats apportioned leads to decrease in the number of seats a certain party holds. Suppose we want to apportion 25 seats between 6 parties in the proportions 1500:1500:900:500:500:200. The two parties with 500 votes get three seats each. Now allocate 26 seats, and it will be found that the these parties get only two seats apiece.
With 25 seats, we get:
Party | A | B | C | D | E | F | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Votes | 1500 | 1500 | 900 | 500 | 500 | 200 | 5100 |
Seats | 25 | ||||||
Hare Quota | 204 | ||||||
Quotas Received | 7.35 | 7.35 | 4.41 | 2.45 | 2.45 | 0.98 | |
Automatic seats | 7 | 7 | 4 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 22 |
Remainder | 0.35 | 0.35 | 0.41 | 0.45 | 0.45 | 0.98 | |
Surplus seats | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 3 |
Total Seats | 7 | 7 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 25 |
With 26 seats, we have:
Party | A | B | C | D | E | F | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Votes | 1500 | 1500 | 900 | 500 | 500 | 200 | 5100 |
Seats | 26 | ||||||
Hare Quota | 196 | ||||||
Quotas Received | 7.65 | 7.65 | 4.59 | 2.55 | 2.55 | 1.02 | |
Automatic seats | 7 | 7 | 4 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 23 |
Remainder | 0.65 | 0.65 | 0.59 | 0.55 | 0.55 | 0.02 | |
Surplus seats | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 |
Total Seats | 8 | 8 | 5 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 26 |
Examples
These examples take an election to allocate 10 seats where there are 100,000 votes.
Hare quota
Party | Yellows | Whites | Reds | Greens | Blues | Pinks | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Votes | 47,000 | 16,000 | 15,800 | 12,000 | 6,100 | 3,100 | 100,000 |
Seats | 10 | ||||||
Hare Quota | 10,000 | ||||||
Votes/Quota | 4.70 | 1.60 | 1.58 | 1.20 | 0.61 | 0.31 | |
Automatic seats | 4 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 7 |
Remainder | 0.70 | 0.60 | 0.58 | 0.20 | 0.61 | 0.31 | |
Highest Remainder Seats | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 |
Total Seats | 5 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 10 |
Droop quota
Party | Yellows | Whites | Reds | Greens | Blues | Pinks | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Votes | 47,000 | 16,000 | 15,800 | 12,000 | 6,100 | 3,100 | 100,000 |
Seats | 10 | ||||||
Droop Quota | 9,091 | ||||||
Votes/Quota | 5.170 | 1.760 | 1.738 | 1.320 | 0.671 | 0.341 | |
Automatic seats | 5 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 8 |
Remainder | 0.170 | 0.760 | 0.738 | 0.320 | 0.671 | 0.341 | |
Highest Remainder Seats | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
Total Seats | 5 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 10 |