Method support poll: Difference between revisions
Content added Content deleted
imported>MarkusSchulze (internal links corrected) |
|||
Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
[[river]], or [[sequential dropping|Smith sequential dropping]], [[CWP|AWP]], [[Candidate withdrawal option|CWO-IRV]], |
[[river]], or [[sequential dropping|Smith sequential dropping]], [[CWP|AWP]], [[Candidate withdrawal option|CWO-IRV]], |
||
[[ER-IRV|ER-IRV(whole)]], [[Approval voting]], [[ER-IRV|ER-IRV(fractional)]], [[IRV]] |
[[ER-IRV|ER-IRV(whole)]], [[Approval voting]], [[ER-IRV|ER-IRV(fractional)]], [[IRV]] |
||
'''Close to supporting:''' [[Definite Majority Choice|DMC]]/[[Ranked Approval Voting|RAV]], [[Smith//IRV]], [[CDTT|CDTT,IRV]], [[Smith//minimax]] |
'''Close to supporting:''' [[Definite Majority Choice|DMC]]/[[Ranked Approval Voting|RAV]], [[Smith//IRV]], [[CDTT|CDTT,IRV]], [[Smith//Minimax|Smith//minimax]] |
||
'''Oppose:''' [[Borda count]] |
'''Oppose:''' [[Borda count]] |
||
'''Close to opposing:''' [[Minimax|minmax]], [[MMPO]], [[Bucklin]], [[Descending Acquiescing Coalitions]] |
'''Close to opposing:''' [[Minimax|minmax]], [[MMPO]], [[Bucklin voting|Bucklin]], [[Descending Acquiescing Coalitions]] |
||
*'''Kevin Venzke''' |
*'''Kevin Venzke''' |
||
Line 51: | Line 51: | ||
'''Support:''' [[IRV]] |
'''Support:''' [[IRV]] |
||
'''Close to supporting:'''[[Condorcet Criterion|Condorcet]]- any completion method, [[top-two runoff]]. |
'''Close to supporting:'''[[Condorcet Criterion|Condorcet]]- any completion method, [[top-two runoff]]. |
||
'''An improvement on [[Plurality]]:''' [[Approval voting]], [[Bucklin]], [[Range voting]]. |
'''An improvement on [[Plurality]]:''' [[Approval voting]], [[Bucklin voting|Bucklin]], [[Range voting]]. |
||
'''Close to opposing:''' [[Borda count|Borda]]. |
'''Close to opposing:''' [[Borda count|Borda]]. |
||
'''Oppose:''' [[Plurality]], the use of single seat methods in multi-member districts. |
'''Oppose:''' [[Plurality]], the use of single seat methods in multi-member districts. |
||
*'''Mike Ossipoff''' |
*'''Mike Ossipoff''' |
||
'''Support:''' [[SSD, and Methods that meet FBC]]. These include [[Approval]], [[Range Voting]], [[MDDA]], [[MDDB]], |
'''Support:''' [[SSD]], and Methods that meet [[Favorite Betrayal criterion|FBC]]. These include [[Approval voting|Approval]], [[Range voting|Range Voting]], [[MDDA]], [[MDDB]], |
||
[[MDD,ER-Bucklin(whole)]], and [[MAMPO]]. |
[[MDD]], [[ER-Bucklin|ER-Bucklin(whole)]], and [[MAMPO]]. |
||
'''Oppose:''' |
'''Oppose:''' methods other than [[SSD]] that don't meet [[Favorite Betrayal criterion|FBC]] |
||
(I'm referring to what I'd support or propose when a proposal is being chosen, not what I'd |
(I'm referring to what I'd support or propose when a proposal is being chosen, not what I'd |