User:RobLa/BResp/Rule A: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted

Inline

Revision as of 21:32, 14 April 2020

DRAFT - As of 2020-04-14, "Rule A" has not been incorporated into the policy of any wiki, forum, or mailing list.

This is the 2020-03-04 draft of "Rule A" of the "Bill of Responsibilites" for users of this site. See User:RobLa/Bill of Responsibilities for the full list.

Please don't let banner blindness prevent you from reading the note immediately below:

Definitions

"Bill of Responsibilites - see User:RobLa/BResp
"Forum" - A "Forum" in this document is a wiki, mailing list, or other online discusssion forum. These will all be referred to as "Forum" for purposes of this document.

Structure - This page will be broken up into many sections. Some of them are specific to the wiki ("Forum") this document is hosted on. Others will be for Forums hosted elsewhere.

Rule A - With freedom of speech comes the responsibility to use it wisely.

Though the First Amendment to the United States Constitution guaranties American citizens freedom of speech, Rule A ensures that every user of this Forum uses this freedom responsibly. This Forum has a code of conduct, and "Rule A" is an introduction to the other rules of this Forum. The Forum may be hosted on a site that has its own code of conduct. If so those rules need to be followed, too.

Comparison to the US First Amendment

This rule is intended to be a counterpart to the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. Particularly the "freedom of speech" part. The First Amendment to the United States Constitution states:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

There's a lot mixed up in that. Some things that people often cite out as core principles of the U.S. Constitution derived from the First Amendment:

Freedom of speech
Separation of church and state (broken up into "separationists" and "accomodationists")
Free exercise of religion
Freedom of the press
Freedom of anonymous speech
Freedom to speak truth to power

Each of these may need to have separate rules. For purposes of this set of rules, "Rule A" will focus on "freedom of speech".

As of 06:29, 14 April 2020 (UTC), "Rule A" will focus on "freedom of speech". TODO: remove this note before finalizing.

Specific rules per site/forum

This section is site-specific prose for each of the given Forums:

Electowiki

In addition to the Bill of Responsibilites, Electowiki is subject to the Miraheze Code of Conduct.

Election methods mailing list

The Bill of Responsibilites is intended to replace the [EM] Code of Conduct, for which the April 2020 version is quoted here:

Please come prepared to defend the statements that you make, and to directly answer the questions that others ask of you. This list was set up to increase communication between people interested in new forms of election methodology, not as a sounding board for those who wish to drown out opposing views with prolific repetition of statements already made. When conflicts arise, please use this list to understand fully why the other side feels the way they do by honest intellectual inquiry. And when those who feel differently than you are trying to understand why you feel the way you do, please answer as honestly and directly as possible. Hopefully this is all common sense, but sadly not common enough (hence the reason for this message). In summary, please ask, answer, and be humble.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-This is the 2020-03-04 draft of "Rule A" of the "Bill of Responsibilites" for users of this site.  See [[User:RobLa/Bill of Responsibilities]] for the full list.
+{{notice|1='''DRAFT''' - As of 2020-04-14, "Rule A" has not been incorporated into the policy of any wiki, forum, or mailing list.  }}This is the 2020-03-04 draft of "Rule A" of the "Bill of Responsibilites" for users of this site.  See [[User:RobLa/Bill of Responsibilities]] for the full list.
 Please don't let banner blindness prevent you from reading the note immediately below:
+{{notice|1='''Definitions
-{{notice|1='''Definition of "forum"''' - This page will be broken up into many sections. Some of them are specific to the wiki this document is hosted on. Others will be for mailing lists, forums, etc.  }}
+* '''"Bill of Responsibilites''' - see [[User:RobLa/BResp]]
-== Rule A - With freedom of speech comes the responsibility to use it wisely. ==
+* '''"Forum"''' - A "Forum" in this document is a wiki, mailing list, or other online discusssion forum.  These will all be referred to as "Forum" for purposes of this document.
-This rule is intended to be a counterpart to the [[W:First Amendment to the United States Constitution|First Amendment to the United States Constitution]].  Particularly the "freedom of speech" part.
+'''Structure''' - This page will be broken up into many sections. Some of them are specific to the wiki ("Forum") this document is hosted on.  Others will be for Forums hosted elsewhere.  }}
+== Rule A - With freedom of speech comes the responsibility to use it wisely. ==
+Though the [[W:First Amendment to the United States Constitution|First Amendment to the United States Constitution]] guaranties American citizens freedom of speech, Rule A ensures that every user of this Forum uses this freedom responsibly. This Forum has a code of conduct, and "Rule A" is an introduction to the other rules of this Forum.  The Forum may be hosted on a site that has its own code of conduct.  If so those rules need to be followed, too.
 === Comparison to the US First Amendment ===
-The [[wikipedia:First Amendment to the United States Constitution|First Amendment to the United States Constitution]] states:
+This rule is intended to be a counterpart to the [[W:First Amendment to the United States Constitution|First Amendment to the United States Constitution]].  Particularly the "freedom of speech" part.  The [[wikipedia:First Amendment to the United States Constitution|First Amendment to the United States Constitution]] states:
 :''Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.''
@@ Line 27: / Line 30: @@
 == Specific rules per site/forum ==
-This section is site-specific prose for each of the given sites/forums:
+This section is site-specific prose for each of the given Forums:
 === Electowiki ===
+In addition to the Bill of Responsibilites, Electowiki is subject to the [https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Code_of_Conduct Miraheze Code of Conduct].
-(put Electowiki stuff here)
+=== Election methods mailing list ===
+The Bill of Responsibilites is intended to replace the [https://electorama.com/em/ <nowiki>[EM] Code of Conduct</nowiki>], for which the April 2020 version is quoted here:<blockquote>Please come prepared to defend the statements that you make, and to directly answer the questions that others ask of you. This list was set up to increase communication between people interested in new forms of election methodology, not as a sounding board for those who wish to drown out opposing views with prolific repetition of statements already made. When conflicts arise, please use this list to understand ''fully'' why the other side feels the way they do by honest intellectual inquiry. And when those who feel differently than you are trying to understand why you feel the way you do, please answer as honestly and directly as possible.
+Hopefully this is all common sense, but sadly not common enough (hence the reason for this message). In summary, please ask, answer, and be humble.</blockquote><br />