Favorite betrayal criterion: Difference between revisions
Content added Content deleted
(Added citation hinted at by User:Masiarek, and added caveat regarding the reasoning for approval voting passing this criterion.) |
(Removed Symmetrical ICT from complying methods, as it doesn't actually pass.) |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
==Complying methods== |
==Complying methods== |
||
[[Approval voting]], [[range voting]], [[Majority Judgment]], [[MMPO|MinMax(pairwise opposition)]], [[MCA]] (except MCA-A and some versions of MCA-R), [[MAMPO]], [[Majority Defeat Disqualification Approval]], and [[Improved Condorcet Approval]] comply with the favorite betrayal criterion, as |
[[Approval voting]], [[range voting]], [[Majority Judgment]], [[MMPO|MinMax(pairwise opposition)]], [[MCA]] (except MCA-A and some versions of MCA-R), [[MAMPO]], [[Majority Defeat Disqualification Approval]], and [[Improved Condorcet Approval]] comply with the favorite betrayal criterion, as does ICT. |
||
[[Borda count]], [[plurality voting]], [[Condorcet criterion|Condorcet methods]] (except for Improved Condorcet methods, such as Kevin Venzke's [[ICA]], and Chris Benham's ICT |
[[Borda count]], [[plurality voting]], [[Condorcet criterion|Condorcet methods]] (except for Improved Condorcet methods, such as Kevin Venzke's [[ICA]], and Chris Benham's ICT) and [[instant-runoff voting]] do not comply.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://lists.electorama.com/pipermail/election-methods-electorama.com/2005-May/081273.html|title=WV methods fail FBC with 3 candidates|website=Election-methods mailing list archives|date=2005-05-13|last=Venzke|first=K.}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=https://munsterhjelm.no/km/yahoo_lists_archive/RangeVoting/web/2005-October/msg00059.html|title=I told why CC is incompatible with FBC. Why the continuing debate?|date=2005-10-18|last=Ossipoff|first=M.|website=RangeVoting Yahoo list mirror}}</ref> |
||
== Examples == |
== Examples == |