Method evaluation poll 2008

From electowiki

Please rate the following single-winner methods on a scale from 0 to 10, on functional merit alone. That is, leaving the issue of public salability aside, how well will the method perform in a large, contentious electorate? Decimal ratings are allowed.

The answers you give on your first pass through the survey need not be final. Please feel free to change/update your answers as many times as you like. You may leave a question mark next to your score for a given method if you are particularly uncertain about that score, and you may also substitute a question mark for the number if you feel unable to evalute the method.

Feel free to add more methods to the poll, especially interesting ones! This goes without saying, but please don't change other people's ratings! Try to keep the columns tidy so that it's clear whose scores are whose. The format of this poll is based on that of the essential questions poll. Please identify yourself by your initials in the body of the poll, and in the participants section at the top of the poll. This poll will be ongoing; that is, it has no closing date. Also, there is no official tally method, and no official winner will be declared.

the participants

 KV - Kevin Venzke
 DS - Diego Santos

the methods

binary input

   KV  DS
    2   1
Two round runoff
    5   4
    7   6
Random Ballot
    0   0

ranking input

not Condorcet-efficient

   KV  DS
Borda count
    0   3
IRV without equal rankings
    3   5
Bucklin without equal rankings
    6   6
    6   6

partially Condorcet-efficient

   KV  DS
minmax(pairwise opposition)
    4   6
Improved Condorcet Approval (ICA, a.k.a. Condorcet//Approval with FBC tweak)
    8   7


   KV  DS
    7   8
    3   5
    6   6
    3   4
Smith,IRV or Schwartz,IRV
    5   9
Condorcet//Approval with implicit ranking = approval
    7   8

ranking input with explicit approval cutoff

   KV  DS
definite majority choice a.k.a. ranked approval voting
    4   9
    3   7

rating input

   KV  DS
range voting (ratings summation)
    5   6


   KV  DS
 Vote For and Against
    5   4
 VFA Runoff
    7   6

See also